top of page

The Succession Plan That Exists Until Someone Resigns

Nov 9
5 min read
By Christopher ED Graham FCIPD, ACTP
By Christopher ED Graham FCIPD, ACTP

Why choosing the next leader is only part of preparing a business for its future.

Most organisations would like to believe they have a succession plan for their senior leadership positions. Potential successors have been identified, development plans discussed and names presented to the board.

Everything appears reassuringly organised. Until someone actually resigns.

The difficulty is that succession planning can create confidence without necessarily establishing whether the organisation is prepared for what comes next. Identifying a replacement is one thing. Understanding whether that individual, the leadership team and the wider business are equipped for the next chapter is quite another.

The person best suited to continue yesterday's success may not be the person needed to deliver tomorrow's strategy.

One Successor Is a Rather Expensive Bet

Identifying a preferred successor is understandable. Allowing that preference to become the only credible option is considerably harder to justify.

People change their minds, receive competing offers or discover that the position they once wanted is no longer particularly attractive. The organisation's requirements may also change while its chosen successor is being developed.

Where sufficient leadership depth exists, preparing at least two credible internal candidates provides choice and reduces dependence on a single individual. Different strengths may emerge as the business evolves, and the candidate who initially appeared the obvious choice may not ultimately be the most suitable.

Transparency matters. Potential successors should understand the opportunities available, the capabilities they need to develop and the fact that consideration does not constitute a promise of promotion.

There is a balance between openness and creating an internal competition that undermines collaboration. Handled well, succession planning should encourage development rather than political manoeuvring.

And if an organisation cannot identify two credible candidates, that is useful information in itself. It reveals a vulnerability that deserves attention, not another name added to a spreadsheet.

Developing Leaders for the Business They Will Inherit

Leadership potential is not the same as leadership readiness.

An accomplished CFO may be capable of becoming CEO but need greater exposure to commercial strategy, investor relations or international operations. A successful consulting Partner may require experience managing a larger practice, developing other Partners or making decisions beyond their own client portfolio.

These are not necessarily reasons to look elsewhere. They are opportunities for deliberate development.

Executive coaching, broader responsibilities, mentoring and carefully chosen assignments can help potential successors develop capabilities they have not yet demonstrated. The important consideration is whether that development reflects where the business is heading.

An organisation preparing for international expansion needs different leadership strengths from one undergoing restructuring. A company pursuing technological transformation may require a different outlook from one focused on operational consistency.

Succession planning should therefore begin with the future direction of the business, not simply the current occupant's job description.

The Value and Limitations of Institutional Knowledge

Long-serving executives bring considerable advantages. They understand the organisation's history, relationships, culture and the reasons certain decisions were made.

That knowledge can preserve stability during a transition. It can also become a limitation when established practices are treated as unquestionable.

The distinction is not simply between insiders and outsiders, but between leaders who understand the business and those capable of challenging it constructively.

Apple provides an interesting illustration.

Steve Jobs was closely associated with Apple's product vision and willingness to challenge established markets. Jony Ive played a defining role in translating that vision into products, while Tim Cook brought different strengths in operations, execution and scaling the business.

Cook did not attempt to reproduce Jobs. Under his leadership, Apple expanded its global business, developed new product categories and substantially grew its services operations.

That raises a question relevant to any board considering succession: does the organisation need someone to preserve a successful model, improve it or fundamentally change it?

There is no universally correct answer.

Rolex, for example, demonstrates the enduring commercial appeal of disciplined evolution, product consistency and brand continuity. Other businesses depend more heavily on challenging existing assumptions and creating entirely new markets.

Both approaches can be successful. The mistake is assuming that the leadership capabilities required for one will necessarily deliver the other.

A New Leader Does Not Arrive Alone

Leadership transitions are frequently discussed as though appointing the right individual determines the outcome.

In practice, senior executives depend on the capabilities, relationships and confidence of the people around them.

A successor may inherit a cohesive management team with complementary strengths. Alternatively, they may encounter competing interests, resistance to change or colleagues whose ambitions have been affected by the appointment.

Some will welcome a new direction. Others may decide that the organisation is no longer where they wish to build their careers.

Formula 1 offers a particularly visible illustration of collective performance.

Christian Horner's long tenure at Red Bull included periods of extraordinary success, while Toto Wolff's leadership at Mercedes has demonstrated the importance of building and sustaining a competitive organisation. Ferrari's experience shows that considerable financial resources, exceptional drivers and a distinguished history do not automatically translate into consistent championship success.

Drivers attract the headlines, but results depend on technical leadership, engineering, strategy, operational discipline and the ability of talented individuals to work effectively together under considerable pressure.

The same applies in business.

A newly appointed CEO or Managing Partner may need to reshape the executive team, introduce capabilities the organisation lacks or reconsider relationships and practices that no longer support its strategy.

Replacing the leader without considering the organisation around them can leave the underlying problems untouched.

Sometimes the Best Internal Candidate No Longer Works There

There is another group organisations can overlook: former employees.

An executive who left five years earlier may have gained international experience, led a transformation, developed commercial relationships or learned different ways of operating.

They may now possess capabilities that were unavailable to them while working within the original organisation.

Returning leaders can offer an attractive combination of institutional understanding and external perspective. They know something of the culture without necessarily being constrained by its current assumptions.

Of course, familiarity should not substitute for proper assessment. Both the business and the individual may have changed considerably.

But excluding former employees simply because they left can unnecessarily narrow the field.

Leadership talent does not stop developing when someone leaves the payroll.

Preparing for the Transition, Not Just the Appointment

Even a carefully managed leadership transition can produce uncertainty.

Relationships need to be established, decisions reconsidered and expectations adjusted. Performance may temporarily decline while the new leader establishes authority and the organisation adapts.

That does not automatically indicate a poor appointment. Equally, boards should not assume that every difficulty is simply part of the settling-in period.

The distinction lies in understanding what success should look like, what support the incoming leader requires and which indicators genuinely matter.

A credible transition plan should consider the leadership team, the capabilities required to execute the strategy, the potential loss of key people and the time needed for changes to take effect.

External benchmarking adds another important dimension.

Understanding how comparable organisations structure leadership, develop successors and respond to changing market conditions provides context that internal assessments alone may not offer.

It may also reveal whether the organisation has the capabilities to deliver its strategy or whether additional appointments are necessary.

The objective should be to make an informed choice between credible internal candidates, returning talent and external leaders, rather than treating an external search as a last resort.

A successful succession plan gives a business options, prepares people for responsibilities they have yet to assume and recognises that changing the leader may also require changing the organisation around them.

Because when someone leaves, the question should not simply be who can take their place.

It should be who can lead the business to where it needs to go next.

C Graham Consulting specialises in retained executive search for C-suite, Director and Partner appointments across financial services, consulting and technology, with international coverage across Europe, Asia-Pacific and North America.

 
 
 

Comments


Home | C Graham Consulting | Executive Coaching, Talent Acquisition Consulting, Interview Coaching, and Global Executive Search | Based in Singapore & France

CGC

insights

bottom of page